After an extended hiatus I'm back writing about politics again. According to the internet I have one followers so, to those disappointed masses, fear not. I'm back.
I have been absorbing a bunch of post election breakdown and will eventually post about some of my research and some of the other cool things i've encountered relative to that. First I want to brainstorm about Gay Marriage. I don't think I know that many folks that think it's a bad idea. However, it has been on the ballot in 30 states and 30 states have rejected it. It thus seems obvious that we need new strategies for talking about it.
This is a great interview between Mike Huckabee and Jon Stewart.
I think it helps show how logically indefensible the anti-gay marriage position is. I also wonder if we just need more of this or if the rational arguments on the subject are not likely to succeed. Dr. Rowland teaches his undergraduate students that a logical argument is not likely to succeed if a: people have already taken their position and b: there is no new information or c: if it is a value issue d: it is a highly complex issue. However, he argus that over time the logical position tends to win out. Do we just need more time? Do we have any new information? If not, we may need new strategies. My suspicion is that we do need new strategies and starting with happy California couples who's marriages were voided is not a bad idea. We should share these stories, and see if we can't get others to realize that their position on the definition of marriage is really hurtful to some.
Here is another interesting argument that is all over the internet these days:
It certainly plays with form. It uses celebrities and appeals to reason as well as self interest. I wonder if it isn't just a new packaging of the old strategies though. I suspect we need to find other ways to articulate our positions. Thoughts?
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Tuesday, November 4, 2008
The Election
What to watch today, and my predictions:
BTW, I am totally indebted to www.fivethirtyeight.com. I voraciously read anything I can get my hands on about the election but constantly turn to this website for all my info.
Number 1: Prop 8 in California is a major cultural issue for us. Will the people of California vote to ban gay marriage? I think it is a toss up, I have no idea.
Number 2: Al Franken. The Senate is very interesting this year. The Democrats should be safe in all of their defenses and should pick up seats in Virginia (Senator Warner has a nice ring to it : ), New Mexico, Alaska (anyone feel bad for Ted Stevens?), Colorado, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and Oregon. That would bring the Democrat lead in the Senate to 58 (counting the two independents. Georgia could be 59. Saxby Chambliss has a small lead in all polling but I personally think the Georgia polls will be conservative by about 3-4 points because “likely voter” polls will discount a lot of new black and young voters, something that I think factors heavily in Georgia. Chambliss also deserves to lose after what he did to Max Cleland (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A14474-2002Jun19.html) so I’m giving Martin a karmic edge too. I’m really looking to see if one of my favorite political satirists can push the democrats into 59/60 territory. Keep an eye on that Minnesota race, it’s a true toss up. Remember, this is the state of Jesse Ventura.
Number 3: How far will Obama run up the score? I think 290 is almost certain. I think a reasonable ceiling is 396 (to get 400 he would need Arizona or South Carolina or West Virginia or something crazy like that. I guess Louisiana could go, that stat is crazy in terms of politics, but it should be solid McCain state. I think Obama will get 354, losing Missouri, Ohio and Indiana but winning Georgia, Florida, Virginia, North Carolina and most of the South West and Mountain West. I could easily be wrong about Missouri and Ohio and may be overestimating Georgia.
If you are just watching for the presidency you can go to be after they call Virginia and Pennsylvania for Obama.
BTW, I am totally indebted to www.fivethirtyeight.com. I voraciously read anything I can get my hands on about the election but constantly turn to this website for all my info.
Number 1: Prop 8 in California is a major cultural issue for us. Will the people of California vote to ban gay marriage? I think it is a toss up, I have no idea.
Number 2: Al Franken. The Senate is very interesting this year. The Democrats should be safe in all of their defenses and should pick up seats in Virginia (Senator Warner has a nice ring to it : ), New Mexico, Alaska (anyone feel bad for Ted Stevens?), Colorado, New Hampshire, North Carolina, and Oregon. That would bring the Democrat lead in the Senate to 58 (counting the two independents. Georgia could be 59. Saxby Chambliss has a small lead in all polling but I personally think the Georgia polls will be conservative by about 3-4 points because “likely voter” polls will discount a lot of new black and young voters, something that I think factors heavily in Georgia. Chambliss also deserves to lose after what he did to Max Cleland (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A14474-2002Jun19.html) so I’m giving Martin a karmic edge too. I’m really looking to see if one of my favorite political satirists can push the democrats into 59/60 territory. Keep an eye on that Minnesota race, it’s a true toss up. Remember, this is the state of Jesse Ventura.
Number 3: How far will Obama run up the score? I think 290 is almost certain. I think a reasonable ceiling is 396 (to get 400 he would need Arizona or South Carolina or West Virginia or something crazy like that. I guess Louisiana could go, that stat is crazy in terms of politics, but it should be solid McCain state. I think Obama will get 354, losing Missouri, Ohio and Indiana but winning Georgia, Florida, Virginia, North Carolina and most of the South West and Mountain West. I could easily be wrong about Missouri and Ohio and may be overestimating Georgia.
If you are just watching for the presidency you can go to be after they call Virginia and Pennsylvania for Obama.
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
How to spot a racist
This campaign is not about race. It’s one of the great things about the Obama candidacy, we are on the brink of a historic moment and it seems like a footnote in an election defined by much bigger issues. In other words, race is not much of a political story right now.
However, politics is an important race story. So what can we learn about racial politics in America because of this election? We learn that racists speak in code. Code is used to deceive others, to deceive yourself maybe. Most importantly, code is used to communicate to those who may be afraid to speak their prejudice out loud.
My favorite incarnation of this is the speech about race that Obama gave a while ago in response to the Rev. Wright controversy. If you missed it you really should give it a look: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2008/03/18/us/politics/20080318_OBAMA_GRAPHIC.html
Early in the semester Ray Strother (http://www.strotherduffystrother.com/) told a class I was in that when someone says “I just don’t know enough about Obama” they really mean “I am not comfortable voting for a black man.” How can you tell? He has campaigned for 17 months, been in 3 presidential debates and dozens of primary debates, he has written 2 books about himself, run more advertising than any candidate ever, been the subject of endless news coverage and has one of the most extensive and easy to navigate websites ever created. If you don’t know much about Obama it’s not because there isn’t a lot to know. In fact, how would one know a bunch about McCain and not enough about Obama? Have they been watching Senate debates on C-Span for the decades he’s been in office? No, at this point that is code.
More code: “he’s not like you and me,” “he’s a secret Muslim,” “he’s a radical/extremist,” “he’s too risky,” “Barak HUSSEIN Obama,” etc. etc. etc. All of these are stand in phrases for “I’m not sure I can vote for a person of color.” How is he “not like us” any more or less than any other politician we’ve ever voted for? What is “risky” about him and not some other Democrat or Republican? Where does this radicalism come from?
Tell me this isn’t race code:
If you don’t believe this is race baiting then tell me how Palin caught so many fish with it:
Look at what civil rights icon John Lewis had to say about the situation:
http://www.politico.com/blogs/jonathanmartin/1008/John_Lewis_invoking_George_Wallace_says_McCain_and_Palin_playing_with_fire.html
Also, watch for familiar plot lines to come up. Dangerous black man hunts helpless white woman is a popular story. If you make the characters the appropriate race and gender you can insert the plot and not say a think about race, the stereotype is already invoked. Here are two examples of this story emerging in the campaign:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/10/24/mccain-supporter-who-clai_n_137484.html
In any event, I believe that we can still learn a lot about racial politics in this country by watching how people talk and act regarding the Obama candidacy. Thoughts?
However, politics is an important race story. So what can we learn about racial politics in America because of this election? We learn that racists speak in code. Code is used to deceive others, to deceive yourself maybe. Most importantly, code is used to communicate to those who may be afraid to speak their prejudice out loud.
My favorite incarnation of this is the speech about race that Obama gave a while ago in response to the Rev. Wright controversy. If you missed it you really should give it a look: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2008/03/18/us/politics/20080318_OBAMA_GRAPHIC.html
Early in the semester Ray Strother (http://www.strotherduffystrother.com/) told a class I was in that when someone says “I just don’t know enough about Obama” they really mean “I am not comfortable voting for a black man.” How can you tell? He has campaigned for 17 months, been in 3 presidential debates and dozens of primary debates, he has written 2 books about himself, run more advertising than any candidate ever, been the subject of endless news coverage and has one of the most extensive and easy to navigate websites ever created. If you don’t know much about Obama it’s not because there isn’t a lot to know. In fact, how would one know a bunch about McCain and not enough about Obama? Have they been watching Senate debates on C-Span for the decades he’s been in office? No, at this point that is code.
More code: “he’s not like you and me,” “he’s a secret Muslim,” “he’s a radical/extremist,” “he’s too risky,” “Barak HUSSEIN Obama,” etc. etc. etc. All of these are stand in phrases for “I’m not sure I can vote for a person of color.” How is he “not like us” any more or less than any other politician we’ve ever voted for? What is “risky” about him and not some other Democrat or Republican? Where does this radicalism come from?
Tell me this isn’t race code:
If you don’t believe this is race baiting then tell me how Palin caught so many fish with it:
Look at what civil rights icon John Lewis had to say about the situation:
http://www.politico.com/blogs/jonathanmartin/1008/John_Lewis_invoking_George_Wallace_says_McCain_and_Palin_playing_with_fire.html
Also, watch for familiar plot lines to come up. Dangerous black man hunts helpless white woman is a popular story. If you make the characters the appropriate race and gender you can insert the plot and not say a think about race, the stereotype is already invoked. Here are two examples of this story emerging in the campaign:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/10/24/mccain-supporter-who-clai_n_137484.html
In any event, I believe that we can still learn a lot about racial politics in this country by watching how people talk and act regarding the Obama candidacy. Thoughts?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)